Should Requested Permas go in the Banlist topics?, Seriously.

I say No because if people request MFGGcide, their fault if THEY wanna be perma'd. No need to drag it out.

Sorry, can't find a way to express it in words, you just have to know me to understand. Sorry.

Yes, because it is a ban.

No, because the banlist is for people who did something wrong, like flaming, trolling, ect.

I say yes because, well I don't like missing news

And asking for a permaban isn't?

should topics like this be made?
shouldnt be up to the mods/admins?
I say...well so far they are not being added so no.

that wouldnt be wrong, that would be stupid.

This post has been edited by EDGE on Apr 30 2007, 05:46 PM

That's what I was trying to say. THANK YOU.

Yes because "HEY WHERE DID THIS GUY GO?"

I meant topics like this one, asking is something should be done with "subject here".

yes because xgoff and derrike

This post has been edited by LuigiFan on Apr 30 2007, 06:04 PM

If it's a ban it goes in the banlist, or else we would have the ban except for annoying new members who can't stand not being liked by one person and will get all mad if we put them in the ban list list.

I think it's fine that they're listed in the Ban Lists. The Ban Lists are for showing everyone else what not to do, and requesting a perma does fall into that category. Also, people will likely know quicker when members are gone from MFGG from looking at the list.

wait that was me :[

Only people who like to contribute to people's goodbye mission would vote yes.
Why would you want their names to be in the ban list, thats too much honor for them.
They are gonna be gone anyway, if they are ban its ok cuz if they comeback they see why they were banned but if they are gone forever then...there is no reason to post cuz they know they requested the perma.
And the excuse of the "WHERE DID THEY GO?" well people still ask that about members who got banned and their names are up in the banned list.

Hence the point of the banlist topic: to show people what NOT to do.

I always saw the banlist as a tool to show who's banned, not for what not to do, so yeah, I say it should be in there.

exactly.

No, because requesting perma is not against the rules.

The banlist doesn't say "all these people broke the rules," it says "here's what not to do." I would put "requesting a permaban" into the "do not do" category because it generally annoys us.

Makes sense then.