Goomba Sprite Comp., Continues!

Good point.

I rate sprites because I like to, o_0.
EDIT : Either way, now that I feel in the mood I'll review the sprites I just rated.

My god do we got no track on when comps start/end!?

I dunno how long this goes on for, that's why I asked.

My god do we got no track on when comps start/end!?

I dunno how long this goes on for, that's why I asked.

Well that wasn't aimed at you, Iceman, o.o.....It seems like all comps Start/End at a different time.

Ryo : Goomba King
Style Opinion / Rating - Stiff - o.0
Pose - The feet are uneven and he looks like he's gonna fall over...And his head is way off of what it should look like ( of a Goomba )...3
Colors - I see random pixels here and there that you need to clean up, 6
Shading - The shading looks bad from far away, though close up it's okay. 7
Overall - 4
( Seriously, this can be a good sprite but you gotta...I dunno break the whole thing and fix it piece by piece. )
( Any Improvments I Advise : Read above. )

Xander : Sheet
Style Opinion / Rating - o.0 - o.0
Pose - o.0
Colors - Very very nice, it's off from all the rest, this is prolly the lightest shade of brown here no?....Refreshing indeed.
Shading - Again with the SMW style!!!...Kick arse.
Overall - Very, very cool, you never fail to impress me. With all the different styles and all it just r0xx0rs!....10...
( O.O )
( Any Improvments I Advise : Umm...Make one of those Goombaz in teh shoez, =). )

Draco : Sheet
Style Opinion / Rating - MUFFINY!!! - o_0..
Pose - o.0
Colors - Okay, back to dark brown, ain't that dark though, the colors look good together. 8
Shading - Lots and lots of layers!...9
Overall - This sprite has it's own style, in the close up your side views look alittle screwy, but still fine, Muffin Shaped, O_o..10
( Muffin muffin muffin... )
( Any Improvments I Advise : I dunno what I can say... )

Willy : Sheet
Style Opinion / Rating - o.0 - o.0
Pose - Hmm.....The walking animations I'm sure will look insane IN animation, I'm taking a shot but never the less cartoonish!...The shade of the head I don't really like...Doesn't look that good on this Goomba....So....In each frame the Goomba looks very different, which I like/don't like...Can't choose....8
Colors - Again, that brown doesn't look good on his head. 6
Shading - All the shading here makrd it look 3-D!!! 10
Overall - 8
( Maybe a few touches and it will be perfect... )
( Any Improvments I Advise : I said so in the above. )

Willy : Sheet
Style Opinion / Rating - OMFG TD!!!!!1111 - ...o_o;...
Pose - A bajillion poses...I uneedingly have to say I like this one much more than your first...But one thing I hate, those wings, no no no, NO!!!!111...They look too cloudish...And thick...
Colors - Orange hmm yes, better than the other in this case. 9
Shading - Yay!!!....I like this classic shading!....^_^...10
Overall - 9
( Great. )
( Any Improvments I Advise : I dunno really what to say. )

SG : WW Goomba
Style Opinion / Rating - Walking - Poor
Pose - Okay, heeeere we go, why when he walks I see his head twich?.....More like he's sliding, yeah [ Not insulting. ] ......5
Colors - Okay, yes, WWish, a bit, but this doesn't look good on paper, it can show you were aiming for WW but failed...[ Least to me. ].....4
Shading - Shading?...What shading?...2 [ 2 for that one layer. ]
Overall - 3.1
( Nope. )
( Any Improvments I Advise : *Shrugs.*...I can't help you...o_0...Really... )

Eh heh heh heh, had a feeling someone would have thought that
was a walking animation. The goomba is actually just standing,
(Was trying to rip off M&L's battling Goomba's standing animation)
But it appears I didn't word it right. CURSE YOU FLU CURSE YOU!
Darn, the colors are a bit off aren't they? Probably because
of Evil Animation Shop. It keeps on screwing the colors,
even if I try to fix it. And the shading, there's only one "layer"
because the Wind Waker style only had one layer......didn't it? o.O

I r sick 2.

In response to Draco Icebane's comment, since I can't find what page it's on:

Thank you for the criticism, but I do not wish to make outlines of that particular sort on my sprites because I have a certain style. I wish to stick to the elements of my style, and black outlines are one of them. Maybe I'll upgrade to colored outlines in the future, but for now I'm sticking with black.

Eh heh heh heh, had a feeling someone would have thought that
was a walking animation. The goomba is actually just standing,
(Was trying to rip off M&L's battling Goomba's standing animation)

Doesn't look it.

But it appears I didn't word it right. CURSE YOU FLU CURSE YOU!
Darn, the colors are a bit off aren't they? Probably because
of Evil Animation Shop. It keeps on screwing the colors,
even if I try to fix it.

That's too bad...

And the shading, there's only one "layer"
because the Wind Waker style only had one layer......didn't it? o.O

Point?

I r sick 2.

Haunter shall make you both well!

<------

*Haunter used lick*

LICK LICK

I r sick 2.

Haunter shall make you both well!

<------

*Haunter used lick*

LICK LICK

Haunter? He was from the older Pokemon series, right?

I r sick 2.

Haunter shall make you both well!

<------

*Haunter used lick*

LICK LICK

Haunter? He was from the older Pokemon series, right?

*Nod.*

The point being that she based it off Wind Waker. Therefore she made it one layer like the Windwaker graphics.

The point being that she based it off Wind Waker. Therefore she made it one layer like the Windwaker graphics.

Well no ****...I meant either way it doesn't really change the rating, or review for that part.

Have an orange, son.

*Haves one.*...........................>_0!!!! *GOES INSIDE OUT!*

The point being that she based it off Wind Waker. Therefore she made it one layer like the Windwaker graphics.

Then why doesn't it look as good as the Wind Waker graphics? There are many "styles", and some of them just suck.

To Xander- OMG LOL r u sick 2 i r sick but u allready no dat lol
Remind me to never talk like that or use that smily.

It actually took me a long time to do the Wind Waker goomba, I did it like that because I wanted to, not because I'm lazy.
And here's the walking animation. There's two versions.
*Image Removed temporary*
*Image Removed temporary*

Since most of you don't like that goomba sprite that much, I dug out an old one I did way back. Two versions yet again.
*Image Removed temporary*
*Image Removed temporary*

This post has been edited by Salad Girl 88 on Mar 30 2004, 03:24 PM

Pick a response:

A) Well that's just your opinion (haha).

B) Don't ask me, man, I didn't make the sprite.

C) Some people like ants.

Pick a response:

A) Well that's just your opinion (haha).

B) Don't ask me, man, I didn't make the sprite.

C) Some people like ants.

A) OMG I R SO OWN3D =P

B) OkIeS

C) STUPID FAT HOBBIT!

... Rawr!
[edit: this is saposed to Sonic Battle styled, thats why its so blocky, what do you guys think?]