Mario and Luigi, Superstar Saga vs. Partners in Time

Which Mario and Luigi game do you like? The first one was classic.

I expected this.

Honestly the first one; I haven't played PiT yet.

fad

Personally, I loved the first one better. I love them both, but the second one seemed to be based more around "ooh purty" than anything. It felt too linear, too predictable, plot twists excluded. Sure, it had some great locations and great music (Thwomp Volcanooooo~), but overall it wasn't that good. The battle against Princess Shroob was epic, though.

Final Boss Spoilers:

The final "boss" was severely disappointing, though. It would have been better if they had just let it end after Elder Princess Shroob.

I liked the first one better because of the free roam.

Superstar Saga is better, IMO.

I disliked both

I've only played the first one (On emulator), It was okay. I honestly like Paper Mario games more. The amount of stuff you can carry in M&L is ridiculous (it makes the game really easy) and battles are a lot less interesting than in Paper Mario.

I actually thought that Paper Mario battles were not as fun since you can't dodge attacks without wasting a turn.

I didn't like either, but if I had to choose, I would say PiT.
In both, the bosses are amazingly hard, the repetitive enemies get annoying and some of the puzzles are just annoying to get. (I'm currently stuck at the Bowser and Baby Bowser battle in Thwomp Volcano in PiT.)

Superstar Saga is best. I havn't played PiT but the first one looks to be the best.

I liked PiT better. It was my first DS game worth mentioning.

In my honest opinion, PiT was much better.

The Bros. attacks were much better (The original's were too hard to pull off right, and PiT's can do INFINITE DAMAAAAAGE), the sound was higher quality, the animations were better, the gameplay was smoother...I could go on.

However, PiT is a lot more linear. and I mean a LOT. And I HATE extreme linearness but it makes up for that with everything else.

There were no Bros. attacks in PiT, only items.

That's what he means i believe
or is it she cuz he's a girl now

PiT is more fun despite it's linearity. Plus, it's music was pretty good.

Spoilers:

The final battle with Elder Princess Shroob. OH MY GOD. Dramatic music, giant boss, low health, huge attacks, floating battlefield, JUST EPIC. Shrowser was horrible though.

In SSS I'm quite sure they're called Bros. Moves, so when I said "Bros. Attacks", I meant moves that use the Bros. that do damage in general.

Spoilers:

Shrowser was just a fail wannabe attempt at Bowletta.

First, because someone stole the second one from me at school.

Not if you fight every battle in every area.
I easily breezed through the game that way.

Also, PiT was better.

PiT was way too easy once I went through and killed every enemy on the screen. But it was still fun, funny and colorful. I wish, though, there was more freeroaming like in SS. I liked the item system, but not as well as the Bro Moves, as well as babies. Ugh. And the music is awesome, very awesome (Gritzy Desert ftw).

Now SS is awesome it's all about the brothers and their... very epic adventure in a strange land. It's hilarious, fun and not entirely linear. And I DO like the Bro Moves with timing and stuff, not just button mashing. The music here is also really cool (battle theme ftw haha).