Hall of shame, Needs its own thread

Does this count?

I don't think so
They are, at least, in style. He put some work in it.

anyone have my sprites from like six years ago that caused a flame war?

wtf, that's not really so horrible at all

and Weston404 should probably get a warning of some kind for his "OH GOD IT'S HORRIBLE" remark. he could have easily gotten his point across without that sentence.

he recoloured mario and added GIANT EYES

the worse part is this was recently added

I'll claim 50% of that responsibility.

yes it is

Yeah it is

nah, you can tell the guy at least put some effort into it.

Bull.

It is nowhere near bad enough to deserve a place in here.


I'm becoming increasingly disillusioned with the concept of this topic over time, mostly because of people like you three talk behind people's backs about stuff that isn't even inexcusably bad. I thought this topic was originally about things that were so bad that the creator was obviously being ridiculous and not trying (or else trolling). This submission is fairly obviously something that the creator actually tried when making.

Elitism of this sort disgusts me, especially when certain people involved rarely, if ever, submit anything to the main site themselves*. At least the person you're talking crap about is actually contributing.


* Not to be misunderstood as a "make sprites yourself before you criticize" statement, because that would be stupid. My point is that seeing non-contributors talk crap about the efforts of contributors pisses me off in general, when said non-contributors are not providing constructive aid (if they were, they wouldn't be non-contributors).

This post has been edited by Grant on Mar 27 2009, 11:55 PM

Three? You mean me included? ;_;

I might have to pull some more bad sheets out.

Really though, this was about declined sheets that were just so bad they had to be shown.

This post has been edited by Parakarry on Mar 28 2009, 01:24 AM

http://mfgg.net/index.php?act=resdb¶m=02&c=1&id=15938
http://mfgg.net/index.php?act=resdb¶m=02&c=1&id=17410
http://mfgg.net/index.php?act=resdb¶m=02&c=1&id=17402

fghfsfgfjs look at the comments

this one is great, too

why is mario holding his ears

What ever happened to quality control. NO ONE will ever use these.

The last two also are not bad enough to belong in here.


I don't like sounding as if I consider myself a self-appointed policeman for this topic, but honestly, this is getting ridiculous.

Sure, none of those three things are very good, but the solution is to go into the comment threads and give constructive criticism, not post about it here, out of sight, to make fun of them. This thread should be for things that it's pretty obviously worthless to bother with C+C for (see the stuff in the first post, for instance).

I mean seriously, compare the stuff quoted here to the material in the first post. No comparison. Mediocre is very different from godawful.

is the one i posted okay?

because i thought that was pretty horrendous.

IT TOOK HIM LIKE, 20 MINUTES. :D