Sprite Competition's over, Move to Archives

Thank you Pucifur, at least somebody believes me.
If I have to, I will illustrate the process I use to make my tiles.

This post has been edited by Supah-Luigi on Nov 13 2008, 06:36 PM

If you bothered looking properly, you'd notice they aren't edits.

Very descriptive. Seriously, you need to stop yelling and be more detailed.

Look at your clouds, palm trees, chests and those pipe things from the desert.

EDIT: @Nappse, sorry for not being descriptive, InsertNameHere, your pipes only have the top two rows, if you tiled it for more, it would have lines on it.

This post has been edited by thingy on Nov 14 2008, 03:35 AM

The desert tiles are edits, and that is obvious. I was looking at an older sheet when I commented on them the last time.

I do think you need to change the desert tiles a little bit, Supah-Luigi. If you look past a few minor coloring changes, the tiles are pretty much a copy-paste job.

The desert tiles are not edits.-The sand looks completely different. No doubt about it.
-The leaves on my palm tree are a completely different shape. The trunk is the same shape, because I still wanted it to be proportional. It would look pretty bad if I made it thicker or thinner.
- The pipe things bear the greatest resemblance to the original sprites out of all of my desert tiles. The actual pipes & the metal blocks have the same shape, but the detail is different. The base of the pipe things is raised up a bit & the detail was done a bit differently.
If anyone else has problems with any specifics. I will be glad to explain why they look this way.


Attached Image

Will you all stop accusing Super_Luigi of sprite theft/editing? He's clearly stated the differences between his entry and the SMB3 rips, and even provided evidence.

@Supah-Luigi's entry. It's great and all, but it just lacks some form of originality. I mean, it's like you may as well just copy and paste. I'm not saying you are copy& pasting or editting, but I feel like you just focused way too much on the reference, and out popped a new sprite with 50% of it's genes from the reference,and 50% from yourself.

Im with Soiyeruda on that one. If I had to make a game using either of those sprites, I would easily pick Supah-Luigis. They do lack a little originality though.

Anyways, the real reason for my post.
This will be my final WIP entry. After this, expect a final, final one.
Here it is:


C & C please;

any sugestions of things to add?

Fix up the grass shading ( It's a really odd shading technique ) and fix the ? blocks. It's really good though.

The evidence he provided really only solidified the fact that they're edits. He just told us exactly what he did to edit them!

I really don't care personally, but if he is to be in compliance with the rules stated in the first post, those edits shouldn't be allowed.

Amazing! The only thing that is bothering me is that I think the pipes are a little to fat.

Thanks. The only problem is, I just can't seem to fix that issue. I'll keep working on it though, fixing the lighting and what rot.

In the mean time, I've reorganized my sheet a little and have added a few things.

*UPDATE*
This is still a WIP. The internet's down at my house until tomorrow, so I couldn't post this earlier and I'm on a friend's computer right now.
I fixed the bricks and pipes (sorry you had to see the old ones ), and added more tiles.

Still more to come.

Attached Image

looks nice! fix up the ground tiles a bit though.

Sorry... I kinda lied before. Im gonna update again.
Here it is: (Im still not done. 2 days left)

Doesn't cut it. Sorry, but I can see that the shape of the pipe is identical to the original, and you obviously only messed with the leaves to avoid being called on your edit.

Disqualified until you can make your own work.

Tileset preview.

Not bad... Hope to see more soon.

Quick update:
Fixed ground tiles and added a little more to it.

Attached Image

That green block on the right is still a WIP, right?

You know what? I'd really like to apologize for my rude behaviour WAAAYYYYY earlier in this topic. That was uncalled for; besides, this is one of the better recent tileset compos. So again, I'm sorry.

All these entries are looking great, 'specially Nova's and Pucifer's!

Pucifur's tileset is one of my favorites entries so far. Unique style, vibrant colors and very useful for fangames.