OL10 Game Comparison #1

I'm starting a series of Game Comparisons now. I will look at all the reviews, and average out the scores for each section: Gameplay(GP), Graphics(GFX), Sound(SFX), Replay(RP), and Final(F). This will allow us to see which Games the Community as a whole likes the best. I will compare 4 Games each time. If you want a certain game to be reviewed, tell me here. Please note that my method of doing the Final Scores will given different results than what the review gave it. I determine the Final Scores for each game by Averaging out the Gameplay, Graphics, Sound, and Replay sections for that game. Now for the 4 Games!

Super Mario Bros. 4: The Subspace Wars
GP: 5.3
GFX: 5.6
SFX: 5.3
RP: 1.6
F: 4.4

Yes, I know I did mine first. I was curious, ok?

Super Mario Fusion
GP: 9
GFX: 9.8
SFX: 8.6
RP: 9.2
F: 8.9

Super Mario Legacy
GP: 7.5
GFX: 7.5
SFX: 5.5
RP: 7.5
F: 7

Normal Super Mario Bros.
GP: 8.2
GFX: 8.3
SFX: 8.3
RP: 6.5
F: 7.8

So, for this time, Super Mario Fusion is best, then Normal Super Mario Bros., then Super Mario Legacy, then Super Mario Bros. 4: The Subspace Wars is the worst. Try out these games, review them, and tell me what games you want me to compare next!

I'm afraid you're putting a lot of effort into nothing. Because there is an option to list games by score on the mainsite =/

Unless you give an actual review of the games yourself, there is no use for this topic as all you're doing is to mimic a feature that the mainsite already does and does better.

Even if you're only comparing the average points instead of the actual final score that the games got, you're missing the point that good graphics/sound/gameplay/replay values do not make a game popular, which is why the main site does NOT automatically calculate the final score out of these categories.

He's not only comparing the final scores, which the system can't do.

Not to mention the system may glitch up sometimes.

I'm not comparing just the Final Scores though. I'm comparing every part of the game based on every review posted for the game, and fixing up any possible glitches that the system could have.